Episode 84: The Bride! (2026) and Bottom Five Brides

This week, Jay and Mike dig up Maggie Gyllenhaal’s The Bride! (2026), a gloriously unhinged reimagining of the Frankenstein myth starring Jessie Buckley and Christian Bale. Part monster movie, part love story, part feminist fever dream, the film has plenty on its mind and isn’t particularly interested in keeping any of it to itself. But does its audacious mix of romance, rebellion, and resurrection amount to something electrifying, or is this one monster that’s better off dead? After the main review, the guys walk down the aisle with their Bottom Five Brides, celebrating some of cinema’s most memorably disastrous trips to the altar. From cold feet to cold hearts, these brides prove that happily ever after is anything but guaranteed. Finally, Jay and Mike say farewell to another recently departed talent with a special round of Kick Two, Pick Two, celebrating a career that boldly went where few had gone before. Something old, something new, something borrowed, something DEAD! It’s a matrimonial massacre on Filmjitsu, the podcast that wields films like deadly weapons!

THE BRIDE! (2026)

Complete Main Review — Recording Notes

Written and directed by: Maggie Gyllenhaal Running time: 126 minutes Principal cast:

  • Jessie Buckley — Ida / The Bride / Mary Shelley
  • Christian Bale — Frank
  • Annette Bening — Dr. Cornelia Euphronious
  • Penélope Cruz — Myrna Malloy
  • Peter Sarsgaard — Detective Jake Wiles
  • Jake Gyllenhaal — Ronnie Reed
  • John Magaro — Clyde
  • Matthew Maher — James
  • Zlatko Burić — Lupino
  • Jeannie Berlin — Greta

1. OVERALL REACTION — A WONDERFULLY AMBITIOUS MONSTER

I thought The Bride! was outstanding and easily one of the best movies you have assigned me for Filmjitsu.

Interestingly, another of my favorite assignments was Alex Garland’s Men, which also stars Jessie Buckley. So you may be onto something with her.

I went into this knowing the film had received a pretty tepid response, and I came away genuinely surprised that more people weren’t responding to it the way I did.

I absolutely loved the look of this movie. The production design, the makeup, the cinematography, the costumes, the performances, and the sheer energy of the filmmaking are extraordinary.

It’s almost like watching a particularly audacious graphic novel brought to life.

But it’s also an incredibly ambitious screenplay, one that attempts to combine:

  • A feminist reclamation of the Bride of Frankenstein.
  • A story about patriarchal violence and the mistreatment of women.
  • A romance between two people society regards as monsters.
  • An examination of identity, autonomy, and the freedom to love.
  • A gangster movie and a crime investigation.
  • A meditation on Mary Shelley and the legacy of her creation.
  • A deliberately artificial version of 1930s Hollywood and American culture.

Does all of that work perfectly?

No. Absolutely not.

I think Gyllenhaal occasionally loses control of her narrative. Some of the ideas are underdeveloped, and certain things aren’t adequately explained.

But I also found it exhilarating.


2. MAGGIE GYLLENHAAL — WRITER AND DIRECTOR

Gyllenhaal’s feature directorial debut was The Lost Daughter, adapted from Elena Ferrante’s novel, which earned her an Academy Award nomination for adapted screenplay.

But where The Lost Daughter is intimate and psychologically restrained, The Bride! is enormous, aggressive, extravagant, and almost operatic.

I think Gyllenhaal is doing something particularly clever here.

She’s returning to Mary Shelley’s original creation and, even more specifically, to the way Hollywood appropriated that creation in the 1930s.

Then she’s effectively asking what Shelley might think of what was done to her story, particularly the Bride character.

My interpretation is that Gyllenhaal is using Mary Shelley as a proxy for herself, and Shelley is using Ida as a proxy for her own fury.

I’m not saying that’s the only way to understand the movie. But I think it’s an extremely useful way to approach its structure.

And it explains why the film sometimes feels as though it’s being told by someone who isn’t particularly interested in respecting chronology, historical accuracy, or conventional narrative rules.

The central distinction

I don’t think the movie is simply about women rebelling against men.

I think it’s about the way society creates monsters out of people who refuse to conform.

The patriarchy is a major part of that argument, but the film’s sympathy for Frank makes its concerns broader than that.

It’s interested in outsiders, loneliness, rejection, love, and the damage people do when they attempt to define other people’s identities.


3. JESSIE BUCKLEY — THREE IDENTITIES, ONE EXTRAORDINARY PERFORMANCE

Other defining work:Men (2022), I’m Thinking of Ending Things (2020), The Lost Daughter (2021), Women Talking (2022), Hamnet (2025).

I think Buckley gives the film’s greatest performance, and that’s saying something with this cast.

She’s effectively playing three identities, and what impressed me most is how distinct they feel while remaining connected.

Mary Shelley — intellectual fury

Buckley’s Shelley is pure rage and disgust.

She’s extraordinarily verbose, with this almost stream-of-consciousness manner of speaking. She rhymes, she twists phrases, she uses elaborate vocabulary, and she speaks with an aggressive rhythm that sometimes feels closer to performance poetry than ordinary dialogue.

Her accent is fascinating, too.

It sounds rough, earthy, almost working-class rather than genteel or aristocratic. Yet she’s speaking with the vocabulary and intelligence of one of the most important literary figures of her time.

That contrast makes the performance feel particularly radical.

She’s a brilliant woman who has absolutely no interest in behaving the way polite society might expect her to behave.

Production detail: Buckley spent extensive time developing the characters’ voices and physicalities. One of her improvisational exercises, inspired by Allen Ginsberg’s Howl, involved shifting between the personalities in a free-flowing, almost jazz-like manner.

That makes perfect sense to me because there’s something musical about the way she speaks.

Ida — vulnerability, victimhood, and experience

Ida is a very different character.

There’s a sensitivity to her, a vulnerability, and an understandable sense of victimhood.

But she’s not merely a passive victim.

She has witnessed and experienced the abuse and mistreatment of women, particularly within the criminal environment surrounding her.

Her anger is therefore grounded in experience.

And I think this is important: Shelley doesn’t simply invent Ida’s anger. She gives an existing anger a more articulate and aggressive voice.

Ida already possesses the reasons to be furious.

Shelley supplies another means of expressing that fury.

The Bride — a new identity emerges

The Bride is the collision of these two women.

She’s neither entirely Ida nor entirely Shelley.

She’s attempting to understand herself while dealing with fragmented memories, the trauma of her death, Shelley’s possession, and Frank’s lies.

And Buckley makes that struggle visible in everything from her expressions to her physical movements.

There’s something almost feral about her, but there’s also enormous sensitivity.

I love that she can be terrifying, funny, romantic, and profoundly vulnerable within the same performance.

The contradiction of possession

Here’s where the screenplay becomes particularly interesting.

Mary Shelley is furious about women being denied agency.

Yet she’s possessing another woman.

She’s using Ida to express her own concerns and desires, apparently without Ida’s consent.

So Shelley herself is guilty of imposing an identity on another person.

I think that’s one of the film’s most fascinating contradictions, although I’m not entirely convinced the screenplay explores it as fully as it could.

Question for Mike: Did you see Shelley as helping Ida discover her voice, or did you see her as another character exploiting Ida for her own purposes?


4. CHRISTIAN BALE — FRANKENSTEIN’S MONSTER AND THE FEAR OF BEING UNLOVABLE

Other defining work:American Psycho (2000), The Machinist (2004), The Dark Knight trilogy (2005–2012), The Fighter (2010), Vice (2018).

Christian Bale is phenomenal.

I love the design of Frank. He’s covered in scars and staples, and his body looks like something assembled from spare parts.

Yet somehow Bale looks amazing beneath all of it.

And the makeup doesn’t prevent him from delivering an incredibly sensitive performance.

He’s been alive for more than a century, and he’s desperately lonely.

He’s an outsider who has spent his entire existence being rejected by the world.

Why Frank lies

When Ida is reanimated, Frank tells her that they had a romantic relationship before her death.

He’s lying.

And that lie is essential to understanding the character.

On one level, he’s another man attempting to control a woman’s identity and her understanding of their relationship.

But I don’t think he lies because he wants to dominate her.

I think he lies because he cannot imagine that she would willingly love him.

He believes he’s so hideous, so fundamentally unlovable, that the only way to secure affection is to invent a history in which that affection already existed.

He’s trying to manufacture love because he doesn’t believe genuine love is available to him.

And that’s heartbreaking.

The great irony

I think Frank genuinely loves the Bride almost immediately.

And I think he loves her for who she is, including her fury, her eccentricities, and her monstrous qualities.

But he’s so insecure that he cannot trust her to make the same choice about him.

Frank creates the very obstacle to authentic love that he’s trying to overcome.

The lie makes it harder for her to trust him.

And by the end, I think he realizes he never needed to tell it.

The Bride can love him freely.

She doesn’t need to be manipulated into it.

Question for Mike: Did you see Frank as another embodiment of the patriarchy, or as a fundamentally decent character whose loneliness leads him to do something morally wrong?


5. ANNETTE BENING — DR. EUPHRONIOUS AND THE POWER OF CREATION

Other defining work:The Grifters (1990), American Beauty (1999), Being Julia (2004), The Kids Are All Right (2010), Nyad (2023).

Annette Bening is terrific as Dr. Cornelia Euphronious, and I think her character is enormously important to the film’s larger argument.

She’s a scientist whose curiosity has led her to understand the work of Victor Frankenstein.

When Frank comes to her, she has the knowledge and scientific ambition necessary to attempt something extraordinary: bringing a dead woman back to life.

And that creates a wonderful inversion of the Frankenstein mythology.

In the original story, the act of creation is dominated by male ambition.

Here, a woman possesses that scientific authority.

She is the one who can accomplish what Frank cannot.

Science, curiosity, and responsibility

What’s especially interesting about Euphronious is that she’s motivated partly by scientific curiosity.

She’s not simply helping Frank out of sympathy.

She’s fascinated by the possibilities of Frankenstein’s work.

That means she participates in the same ethically complicated act that lies at the heart of the original story.

A woman is brought back to life without having requested it, partly to satisfy someone else’s desire.

Euphronious is therefore not necessarily exempt from the movie’s criticism of people who impose their wishes on others.

But she also becomes essential to the Bride’s ultimate liberation.

Her assistant and the black markings

We also need to discuss the woman working with Euphronious.

Her eventual adoption of the Bride’s black facial markings is a terrific visual detail.

The markings begin as a grotesque consequence of resurrection, almost like smeared black lipstick.

But as the Bride becomes a symbol of rebellion, those markings take on another meaning.

They become a sign of identification and solidarity.

The doctor’s assistant is effectively an acolyte of this movement.

I love that transformation: something originally associated with death and monstrosity becomes a symbol of empowerment.

The final resurrection

Euphronious’s role becomes especially important at the end.

She’s involved in the Bride’s second reanimation, this time with Myrna aware of what is going to happen.

And that changes the significance of the act.

The first resurrection is undertaken to satisfy Frank’s longing for companionship.

The second can be understood as restoring the Bride’s opportunity to live as the person she has become.

That’s an extraordinary difference.

Question for Mike: Do you think Euphronious represents a more enlightened version of Frankenstein’s scientific ambition, or does she initially repeat some of the same mistakes?


6. PENÉLOPE CRUZ AND PETER SARSGAARD — TWO DIFFERENT RESPONSES TO PATRIARCHY

Penélope Cruz — other defining work:Volver (2006), Vicky Cristina Barcelona (2008), All About My Mother (1999), Parallel Mothers (2021).

Peter Sarsgaard — other defining work:Shattered Glass (2003), Garden State (2004), An Education (2009), The Batman (2022), Memory (2023).

Penélope Cruz is absolutely wonderful as Myrna Malloy.

She’s one of my favorite characters in the movie.

Myrna is intelligent, competent, empathetic, and capable of navigating a male-dominated institution without sacrificing her femininity or her humanity.

And I think she represents a very different form of empowerment from the Bride.

Myrna’s alternative to rebellion

The Bride’s response to patriarchal abuse is revolutionary and sometimes violent.

Myrna works within the existing system.

She succeeds through competence, persistence, intelligence, and understanding.

She doesn’t need to humiliate or destroy men to establish her own authority.

She’s frequently the smartest person in the room.

And she knows it.

But she’s also capable of empathy and cooperation.

I think that’s important because the movie doesn’t insist that there’s only one acceptable way for women to assert themselves.

Peter Sarsgaard as Jake Wiles

Sarsgaard is excellent as Detective Jake Wiles, Myrna’s colleague.

He’s a deeply flawed man, and he’s an excellent foil for her.

He’s fallible, capable of poor judgment, and very much a product of the male-dominated system in which they operate.

But he isn’t necessarily evil.

And I think that’s another important element of the film.

Men can be deeply flawed without being irredeemable.

I initially thought Myrna might represent women forgiving men, but I think there’s a more precise way to describe her.

She represents the possibility of cooperation without submission.

She doesn’t have to accept the limitations imposed on her, but she also doesn’t have to regard every man as an enemy.

And her participation in the ending brings her approach to empowerment together with the Bride’s revolutionary one.

Question for Mike: Did Myrna strike you as a deliberate counterpoint to the Bride, or did you think her character existed primarily to move the crime investigation forward?


7. JAKE GYLLENHAAL — RONNIE REED AND THE FANTASY OF LOVE

Other defining work:Donnie Darko (2001), Brokeback Mountain (2005), Zodiac (2007), Nightcrawler (2014), Prisoners (2013).

Jake Gyllenhaal plays Ronnie Reed, a 1930s movie star whom Frank idolizes.

This is another aspect of the movie that I think is more thematically important than it initially appears.

Frank has developed an emotional attachment to someone who exists primarily as an image on a movie screen.

He’s effectively constructed an imaginary relationship with a person who doesn’t know him.

And that tells us an enormous amount about his loneliness.

The Hollywood fantasy

Ronnie represents the kind of idealized romance Frank has absorbed from the movies.

Those old Hollywood musicals offer a world where love is elegant, beautiful, choreographed, and apparently effortless.

But Frank’s actual relationship with the Bride is nothing like that.

It’s grotesque, chaotic, dishonest, passionate, and deeply imperfect.

And ultimately, it’s real.

I think that’s a wonderful contrast.

The movie isn’t simply rejecting romantic fantasy.

It’s suggesting that authentic love is far more complicated, and perhaps far more valuable, than the polished version presented on a movie screen.

The significance of the 1930s

Gyllenhaal has discussed how Frank’s imaginary relationship with a movie star helped determine the period setting.

She was interested in the contrast between the fantasy of Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers-style romance and the messy reality of two monsters attempting to love one another.

That makes Ronnie Reed an important part of the film’s emotional architecture.

Question for Mike: Did the musical and Hollywood fantasy sequences enhance the romance for you, or did they feel like another distracting element in an already overcrowded screenplay?


8. THE ORIGINAL BRIDE OF FRANKENSTEIN — REWRITING THE PREMISE

I have to say something that may be unpopular: I’ve never particularly liked the original Bride of Frankenstein from 1935.

I recognize its visual accomplishments.

It’s an enormously influential movie, and Elsa Lanchester’s appearance as the Bride is one of the most iconic images in horror cinema.

But I’ve always found the storytelling unsatisfying.

And I’ve never thought the film had all its ducks in a row narratively because the Bride is created to satisfy the monster’s desire for companionship.

Her purpose is defined by his loneliness.

And when she rejects him, her rejection becomes part of his tragedy.

She’s barely allowed an identity of her own.

Gyllenhaal takes that premise and turns it inside out.

She asks what the Bride herself might want.

What would she think about being brought back to life?

What would she think about being created for a man?

What would she think about being expected to love someone simply because other people decided she should?

The complexity of Gyllenhaal’s answer

What I love is that Gyllenhaal doesn’t invalidate Frank’s loneliness.

His suffering is real.

His desire for companionship is understandable.

The problem isn’t that he wants to be loved.

The problem is that he initially believes his suffering entitles him to manipulate another person’s affection.

And ultimately, the Bride chooses to love him anyway.

Not because she was created for him.

Because she understands him.

And because he understands her.

That makes their relationship much more complex and emotionally satisfying than the original premise.

Other cinematic connections

The film’s period setting naturally evokes Universal’s Frankenstein (1931) and Bride of Frankenstein (1935).

I also noticed echoes of Mel Brooks’s Young Frankenstein (1974), particularly in the Putting on the Ritz sequence!

Those connections make the film feel as though it’s engaging with the entire cinematic legacy of the monster, rather than simply adapting Shelley’s novel.


9. MARY SHELLEY, PERCY SHELLEY, AND THE IMPORTANCE OF LOVE

One historical detail worth mentioning is Mary Shelley’s preservation of the heart believed to belong to her husband, the Romantic poet Percy Bysshe Shelley.

And the film’s reference to his heart is important.

Love and anger aren’t mutually exclusive

Mary Shelley is presented as a furious figure.

She’s disgusted by the mistreatment of women and by the way her creation has been appropriated.

Yet she’s also someone who experienced profound romantic love.

And I think that matters to the relationship between Frank and the Bride.

The film isn’t suggesting that female anger makes love impossible.

Nor is it suggesting that romantic love requires a woman to abandon her anger or independence.

The Bride can be furious with the world and still love Frank.

And Frank can recognize that fury as part of the person he loves.

That’s a much more interesting romantic argument than simply having two lonely monsters fall in love.


10. CINEMATOGRAPHY — LAWRENCE SHER

Other defining work:Joker (2019), Joker: Folie à Deux (2024), Godzilla: King of the Monsters (2019), The Hangover (2009).

The cinematography is one of the movie’s greatest strengths.

Lawrence Sher, who photographed both Joker movies, creates a world that’s simultaneously recognizable as the 1930s and completely removed from historical realism.

There’s a graphic-novel quality to the imagery.

The lighting, the color palette, the compositions, and the camera movement all contribute to a sense of heightened reality.

The deliberately artificial period

I love that the movie doesn’t seem particularly concerned with being historically accurate.

There are contemporary-looking lights, nightclub environments, music, and other details that seem to belong to different eras.

I noticed things like 3D glasses and modern-feeling club sequences that seem deliberately incongruous.

  • My interpretation is that this reflects Mary Shelley telling the story from outside time.
  • She’s not confined to the historical period in which the events are taking place.

Whether Gyllenhaal intended that exact explanation or not, the visual anachronisms are clearly part of the film’s design.

A particularly interesting influence

Gyllenhaal cited the opening of Ingmar Bergman’s Persona (1966) as an inspiration for the electrical imagery in the laboratory.

That’s a terrific reference because Persona is itself deeply concerned with identity, psychological boundaries, and the merging of personalities.

Those concerns are obviously relevant to Ida and Mary Shelley.


11. PRODUCTION DESIGN — KAREN MURPHY

Other defining work:Elvis (2022), A Star Is Born (2018), Queen & Slim (2019), Nightbitch (2024).

Karen Murphy’s production design is phenomenal.

She was also responsible for the production design of Baz Luhrmann’s Elvis, and I think that connection is particularly useful.

Both films create a heightened interpretation of an earlier historical period.

They’re not simply recreating the past.

They’re using historical imagery to create a distinctive emotional and visual experience.

The world of The Bride!

I love the laboratories, the city streets, the clubs, and the interiors.

Everything feels rich with detail.

But there’s also something deliberately artificial about the environments.

The movie feels like a world that has been constructed according to the logic of a graphic novel.

Murphy drew upon 1930s modernist architecture, avant-garde photography, and artists including Man Ray and Marianne Brandt.

Her background in architecture is especially relevant to the laboratory and the doctor’s estate.

Why the design matters

I think the production design helps reconcile some of the movie’s apparently incompatible influences.

It’s a gangster movie, a horror movie, a romance, and a period fantasy.

The environments have to accommodate all those genres.

And somehow they do.

It’s one of the reasons I found the movie so visually exciting.


12. COSTUME DESIGN — SANDY POWELL

Other defining work:Shakespeare in Love (1998), The Aviator (2004), The Young Victoria (2009), Carol (2015), The Favourite (2018).

Sandy Powell is one of the most accomplished costume designers working in film, with three Academy Awards.

And her work here is fantastic.

The Bride’s clothing is particularly important because it helps establish her identity.

There’s a wonderful combination of period fashion, punk-rock rebellion, and something almost otherworldly.


13. MAKEUP AND PROSTHETICS — NADIA STACEY AND SCOTT STODDARD/JASON COLLINS

Nadia Stacey — other defining work:Poor Things (2023), Cruella (2021), The Favourite (2018).

Scott Stoddard — special-effects makeup designer for The Frank Team:Deadpool 2 (2018), The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003).

Jason Collins — special makeup effects and prosthetic fabrication supervisor: Work through Autonomous FX, including the custom prosthetic and makeup fabrication used on this film.

The makeup and character design are extraordinary.

And I think the Bride’s appearance is one of the great visual achievements of the film.

The black substance

When she’s reanimated, this black substance erupts from her mouth and stains her face.

It looks like smeared black lipstick, but it’s also something more grotesque.

It’s almost as though the resurrection process has forced something poisonous out of her body.

And it creates an instantly recognizable appearance.

Gyllenhaal has explained that the substance is connected to the Bride finding her voice.

She’s literally expelling something from her throat.

The image becomes a visual expression of a woman who has been silenced finally being able to speak.

The artistic influences

Nadia Stacey drew inspiration from a Ralph Steadman portrait of Hunter S. Thompson for the facial splatter.

The design was reproduced using custom temporary tattoos, helping maintain continuity.

Man Ray’s photography also influenced the black markings on the Bride’s body.

I love the way those influences connect the film’s character design to the avant-garde visual traditions of the early twentieth century.

The connection to Poor Things

Stacey also worked on Yorgos Lanthimos’s Poor Things.

That’s a particularly interesting connection because both films feature women brought into unusual forms of life who must develop their identities and discover their independence.

The similarities are thematic as well as visual.

But the films approach their central characters in very different ways.

Frank’s appearance

Frank’s makeup is equally remarkable.

Scott Stoddard’s effects design and the prosthetic fabrication work help create a character who looks physically assembled from different bodies.

But the makeup never completely overwhelms Bale’s performance.

You can still see the loneliness, vulnerability, and sensitivity in his face.

That’s essential to making the romance work.


14. MUSIC — HILDUR GUÐNADÓTTIR AND RANDALL POSTER

Hildur Guðnadóttir — other defining work:Joker (2019), Chernobyl (2019), Women Talking (2022), TÁR (2022). First solo woman composer to win a BAFTA, Academy Award and a Golden Globe for Joker.

Randall Poster — other defining work:The Grand Budapest Hotel (2014), Moonrise Kingdom (2012), The Wolf of Wall Street (2013), Joker (2019).

Randall Poster supervised the music, and his extensive work with Wes Anderson and Martin Scorsese is another impressive connection.

The soundtrack’s deliberately unstable identity

The music is another aspect of the film that refuses to remain in the 1930s.

There are period associations, but also contemporary sounds and an almost punk-rock sensibility.

I love that.

The film is about rebellion, and the soundtrack seems to be rebelling against the conventions of the period setting.

The music includes contributions from Lee Ranaldo of Sonic Youth, saxophonist David Murray, and Fever Ray.

It’s a fascinating combination of sounds.

And I think it contributes enormously to the movie’s emotional intensity.

The Joker connection

It’s worth mentioning that Sher, Guðnadóttir, and Poster all worked on Joker.

That’s an interesting creative connection because both films construct highly stylized worlds around characters who have been alienated from society.

But The Bride! ultimately takes its outsider characters in a much more romantic direction.


15. EDITING — DYLAN TICHENOR

Other defining work:Boogie Nights (1997), Magnolia (1999), The Royal Tenenbaums (2001), There Will Be Blood (2007), Zero Dark Thirty (2012), Phantom Thread (2017).

Dylan Tichenor’s résumé is extraordinary.

He’s worked extensively with Paul Thomas Anderson, including on Boogie Nights, Magnolia, There Will Be Blood, and Phantom Thread.

And I think the editing is an essential part of why The Bride! works as well as it does.

The movie’s velocity

This movie moves.

It shifts constantly between romance, horror, crime, comedy, fantasy, and social commentary.

Sometimes those transitions are abrupt.

And sometimes I think the screenplay simply has too much happening to develop everything properly.

But I found the momentum exhilarating.

There’s a tremendous sense of creative energy.

I don’t think Gyllenhaal ever wants the audience to become comfortable with the movie’s tone or genre.

And Tichenor’s editing helps sustain that instability.

The downside

This is also where some of my reservations emerge.

The movie sometimes feels as though it’s racing through ideas that deserve more attention.

There are moments when I wanted Gyllenhaal to slow down and give her characters more room.

But I never found the movie boring.

And given the scale of its ambitions, that’s an accomplishment in itself.


16. THE ENDING — THE BRIDE BECOMES HERSELF

I think the ending is the key to understanding the movie.

And I think it’s far more satisfying than it might initially appear.

The first resurrection

Ida is brought back to life because Frank wants a companion.

She’s not consulted.

She doesn’t understand who she is.

She’s being influenced by Mary Shelley and deceived by Frank.

She’s alive, but she doesn’t fully possess her own identity.

The second resurrection

By the time she’s brought back at the end, everything has changed.

She’s experienced love, violence, rebellion, betrayal, and self-discovery.

And I believe Mary Shelley has finally departed.

I interpret that as Shelley having fulfilled her purpose.

Ida no longer needs Shelley to speak for her.

She’s developed her own voice.

She’s evolved into the Bride.

But this time, being the Bride is her choice.

What that means for Frank

Frank has changed, too.

He begins the movie believing that love must be manufactured.

He thinks nobody could possibly love him voluntarily.

And so he lies.

But by the end, he’s confronted with the possibility that he was wrong.

The Bride can choose to love him.

And he can finally believe that he’s worthy of that love.

The central argument

Ida’s first resurrection gives her life. Her second resurrection gives her ownership of that life.

That’s how I understand the movie.

The Bride was originally created to satisfy someone else’s desire.

By the end, she’s become someone who can determine her own desires.

And one of those desires is to love Frank.

She doesn’t surrender her independence by choosing him.

She demonstrates it.


17. WHAT DOESN’T WORK?

I don’t want my enthusiasm to obscure the film’s problems.

I think there are legitimate criticisms.

The screenplay is occasionally disjointed

There are a tremendous number of ideas competing for attention.

The crime story, the romance, the Mary Shelley possession, the feminist movement, the Hollywood fantasy sequences, and the social commentary don’t always fit together smoothly.

The possession mythology isn’t fully developed

I understand what Gyllenhaal seems to be attempting with Shelley and Ida.

But I don’t think the movie always makes the mechanics or consequences of that relationship clear.

That ambiguity can be intriguing, but it can also be frustrating.

Some thematic contradictions aren’t completely resolved

Shelley wants women to possess agency, yet she possesses Ida.

Frank wants authentic love, yet he deceives the Bride.

Euphronious is a groundbreaking female scientist, yet she participates in creating a woman for someone else’s benefit.

These contradictions make the film interesting.

But I’m not convinced Gyllenhaal fully explores all of them.

Style sometimes overwhelms storytelling

There are moments when the visual extravagance and sheer number of ideas threaten to overpower the emotional narrative.

But for me, the central performances and love story are strong enough to hold the movie together.


18. FINAL ASSESSMENT — A MONSTER BROUGHT TO LIFE

I loved this movie.

I understand why it might frustrate some viewers.

It’s excessive, occasionally incoherent, and sometimes more interested in its ideas than in fully developing them.

But it’s also tremendously ambitious, visually spectacular, and emotionally affecting.

Jessie Buckley is extraordinary.

Christian Bale gives one of the most sympathetic portrayals of Frankenstein’s monster I’ve seen.

The supporting cast is terrific, particularly Annette Bening and Penélope Cruz.

And the craftsmanship is remarkable, from Lawrence Sher’s cinematography and Karen Murphy’s production design to Sandy Powell’s costumes, Nadia Stacey’s makeup, and Hildur Guðnadóttir’s music.

Gyllenhaal has taken a character who was historically created to satisfy a man’s loneliness and given her a voice, an identity, and the ability to choose her own future.

And I think that’s a remarkable accomplishment.

There’s also something appropriate about the film’s imperfections.

The Bride! is itself something of a Frankenstein monster.

It’s stitched together from disparate genres, literary references, historical periods, cinematic traditions, and thematic concerns.

Not every piece fits perfectly.

But somehow, Gyllenhaal brings the thing to life.

And for me, that makes it a genuinely wonderful movie.


QUICK-REFERENCE PRODUCTION CREDITS

ContributorRoleOther defining work
Maggie GyllenhaalWriter/directorThe Lost Daughter
Lawrence SherCinematographyJoker, Godzilla: King of the Monsters, The Hangover
Karen MurphyProduction designElvis, A Star Is Born, Queen & Slim
Sandy PowellCostume designThe Aviator, Carol, The Favourite
Nadia StaceyMakeup/prosthetics designPoor Things, Cruella, The Favourite
Scott StoddardFrank’s special-effects makeup designDeadpool 2, The Texas Chainsaw Massacre
Jason CollinsProsthetic fabrication supervisionAutonomous FX
Hildur GuðnadóttirOriginal scoreJoker, Chernobyl, Women Talking
Randall PosterMusic supervisionThe Grand Budapest Hotel, The Wolf of Wall Street, Joker
Dylan TichenorEditingBoogie Nights, There Will Be Blood, Phantom Thread
Douglas AibelCastingThe Grand Budapest Hotel, Moonrise Kingdom, The Royal Tenenbaums

Bottom Five Brides

Harriet Michaels – So I Married an Axe Murderer (1993) — Nancy Travis

I absolutely love So I Married an Axe Murderer. I think it’s one of Mike Myers’s funniest movies, and it’s a shame that this wonderfully bizarre romantic comedy was such a spectacular box-office disappointment.

Released in July 1993, the movie was directed by Thomas Schlamme, who would later become an enormously successful television director on shows including The West Wing. It stars Myers as Charlie MacKenzie, a San Francisco beat poet with a serious fear of commitment, and Nancy Travis as Harriet Michaels, the beautiful butcher who may or may not be a serial killer.

The supporting cast is terrific, including Anthony LaPaglia, Amanda Plummer, Brenda Fricker, and Alan Arkin, with memorable appearances by Phil Hartman, Charles Grodin, Steven Wright, and Michael Richards. Myers also plays Charlie’s Scottish father, Stuart, giving us some of the movie’s most gloriously ridiculous moments.

The movie reportedly cost around $20 million to produce but earned only about $11.6 million at the domestic box office. Critics weren’t especially enthusiastic, either, and it currently sits at 55% on Rotten Tomatoes. Nevertheless, it’s developed a devoted following over the years, and I would argue that it remains one of the more underrated comedies of the 1990s.

Its production history is almost as strange as the movie itself.

Robbie Fox originally developed the screenplay years before Myers became involved, and at various points Garry Shandling and Chevy Chase were attached to star. Sharon Stone was also considered for Harriet. The script went through numerous rewrites, with contributors reportedly including Carrie Fisher and Conan O’Brien.

When Myers came aboard following the enormous success of Wayne’s World, he and collaborator Neil Mullarkey substantially reworked the material. That led to a rather contentious Writers Guild arbitration over screenplay credit, which ultimately went solely to Fox.

And here’s an especially interesting detail: contemporary reporting suggested that two versions of the movie’s ending had been filmed, one in which Harriet was guilty and another in which she was innocent.

Which brings me to my selection.

Harriet Michaels is beautiful, charming, funny, and apparently a wonderful woman to marry. There’s just one small problem: her husbands keep fucking disappearing.

Three of them! THREE!

And we’re supposed to believe that Harriet has absolutely no idea what’s happening to them. According to the movie, her sister Rose, played by Amanda Plummer, has been murdering these poor bastards, and Harriet simply assumes they’ve all abandoned her.

Now, I’m sorry, but at what point do you start to notice a pattern? After the second husband vanishes? The third? Do you just keep getting married and hope that number four sticks around?

And here’s what really gets me. Harriet is genuinely afraid that something might happen to Charlie. Well, why the hell would she be worried about that unless she suspected something was going on?

Then there’s that weird moment when Rose tells Harriet, “You know you’re not supposed to be here.” What the hell is THAT supposed to mean?

The screenplay insists Harriet is innocent, and maybe she is. But that doesn’t make her a good bride. At best, she’s catastrophically oblivious to the fact that marrying her is practically a death sentence. At worst, she knows a whole lot more than she’s letting on.

And while the movie wants us to celebrate Charlie finally overcoming his fear of commitment, I can’t help thinking that perhaps the guy had a pretty goddamn good reason to be afraid.

Either way, I wouldn’t be lining up to put a ring on her finger.

Harriet Michaels: three missing husbands, one homicidal sister, and apparently not a single goddamn question.


Justine – Melancholia (2011) — Kirsten Dunst Directed by Lars von Trier

Lars von Trier’s Melancholia is a 2011 psychological drama and science-fiction film starring Kirsten Dunst, Charlotte Gainsbourg, Kiefer Sutherland, Alexander Skarsgård, and Stellan Skarsgård.

Von Trier, who previously directed Breaking the Waves, Dancer in the Dark, and Antichrist, constructed the movie in two halves, each named for one of its central sisters.

The film was made for a reported budget of approximately $9 million and earned a relatively modest amount theatrically, although it became one of the more critically acclaimed films of von Trier’s career. Dunst won Best Actress at Cannes for her performance, despite the considerable controversy surrounding the director at that year’s festival.

Dunst plays Justine, a young woman whose lavish wedding reception becomes an absolute catastrophe. She’s late to her own reception, alienates practically everyone in attendance, cheats on her new husband, and watches her marriage collapse before the honeymoon even begins.

But what makes Justine one of my Bottom Five Brides isn’t simply that she’s a terrible wife. It’s that she’s a terrible bride because she shouldn’t be a bride at all.

The first half of the film depicts a woman practically disintegrating beneath the expectations of marriage. She’s supposed to be celebrating the happiest day of her life, but the identity everyone expects her to assume is fundamentally incompatible with who she is.

And there’s a fascinating parallel to the film’s second half, in which a rogue planet called Melancholia approaches Earth on a collision course.

Marriage is traditionally described as two people becoming one. But for Justine, that union threatens to annihilate her individuality, just as the approaching planet will ultimately annihilate Earth.

The irony is that once her marriage has collapsed, and the world itself is approaching destruction, Justine becomes something approaching a complete person. She’s still suffering, but she’s more composed, more accepting, and ultimately more capable of facing the inevitable than the people around her.

So Justine earns her place on this list not because she’s a terrible woman, but because being a bride is perhaps the worst thing she could possibly be.

And in a movie about the literal end of the world, her wedding somehow manages to be the first apocalypse.


Maggie Carpenter – Runaway Bride (1999) — Julia Roberts

For number three of my Bottom Five Brides. I’m going with Julia Roberts as Maggie Carpenter in Garry Marshall’s 1999 romantic comedy Runaway Bride.

The movie reunites Roberts with Richard Gere, Marshall, and Héctor Elizondo, nine years after the enormous success of Pretty Woman. This time, Gere plays Ike Graham, a cynical New York newspaper columnist who becomes fascinated with Maggie, a small-town Maryland woman who’s developed a rather unfortunate habit of leaving prospective husbands standing at the altar.

The movie also stars Joan Cusack, Rita Wilson, Christopher Meloni, and Paul Dooley, with cinematography by Stuart Dryburgh and music by James Newton Howard.

Written by Josann McGibbon and Sara Parriott, Runaway Bride spent approximately a decade in development before finally reaching theaters. It was also a pretty expensive romantic comedy, with a reported $70 million budget, including roughly $17 million for Roberts and $12 million for Gere.

Fortunately for everyone involved, audiences were apparently eager to see these two fall in love again. The movie opened at number one in July 1999 and eventually grossed about $309.5 million worldwide. Critics were less enthusiastic, and it currently holds a 45% rating on Rotten Tomatoes.

Most of the movie was filmed in Maryland, with the town of Berlin standing in for the fictional Hale. And here’s a fun bit of production trivia: Oscar-winning costume designer Albert Wolsky had to create five wedding dresses for Roberts, with four of the wedding sequences scheduled during the first two weeks of shooting.

Which brings me to Maggie.

When we meet her, Maggie has already abandoned three men at the altar, and she’s preparing to marry a fourth, a high-school football coach played by Christopher Meloni.

And while Maggie has every right to decide she doesn’t want to marry someone, I think we can agree that there’s a difference between calling off an engagement and waiting until the groom is standing in front of a church full of people before making a goddamn run for it.

Three times!

And then, when Ike comes to town to investigate her story, they fall in love, decide to get married, and—wouldn’t you know it—SHE DOES IT AGAIN.

That’s four abandoned weddings. Four devastated grooms. Four sets of guests wondering whether they should still eat the chicken.

But the movie has an interesting explanation for Maggie’s behavior. She has spent so much of her life trying to become the woman each prospective husband wants that she doesn’t really know who she is anymore.

There’s a wonderful recurring detail involving how Maggie likes her eggs. With each fiancé, she claims to prefer them prepared exactly the way he does. It’s only after she’s abandoned Ike that she finally sits down, tries different preparations, and figures out what she actually likes.

It’s a clever metaphor for a woman who has confused being loved with being whatever someone else wants her to be.

And I sympathize with that. I really do.

But here’s the thing: you can absolutely need time to discover yourself without repeatedly inviting two hundred people to watch you discover that you’re not getting married.

Ultimately, Maggie figures herself out, returns to Ike, proposes to him, and they finally get married in a small, private ceremony.

So, unlike some of the other women on this list, Maggie actually gets a happy ending.

But I’m still putting her at number three because the journey to that happy ending is paved with enough abandoned grooms to fill an entire wedding party.

Maggie Carpenter: a woman who needed to find herself, but apparently couldn’t do it without making four other men lose their fucking deposits.


Marylin Rexroth – Intolerable Cruelty (2003) — Catherine Zeta-Jones

In the Coen brothers’ Intolerable Cruelty, Catherine Zeta-Jones plays Marylin Rexroth, a woman who has discovered that marriage can be an extraordinarily lucrative business, provided you have absolutely no objection to ruining the lives of the men you marry.

This 2003 romantic comedy stars George Clooney as Miles Massey, a spectacularly successful divorce attorney, and features Geoffrey Rush, Billy Bob Thornton, Cedric the Entertainer, and Richard Jenkins. It was photographed by the great Roger Deakins, who also shot the Coens’ Fargo and No Country for Old Men, with music by frequent Coen collaborator Carter Burwell.

Interestingly, the Coens didn’t originate the screenplay. They reworked an existing script by Robert Ramsey and Matthew Stone, with John Romano receiving a story credit. The resulting movie is a decidedly old-fashioned screwball comedy, although with a rather nasty contemporary view of marriage.

It was also a fairly expensive proposition, costing approximately $60 million and earning about $121 million worldwide. Not an outright theatrical disaster, but hardly the sort of financial return you’d expect to have studio executives celebrating.

Marylin is beautiful, sophisticated, intelligent, and almost impossibly calculating. When her wealthy husband gets caught cheating, she attempts to take him for everything he’s worth, only to run into Miles, who’s so good at protecting adulterous husbands that he’s practically made marital misery into an art form.

What follows is a wonderfully convoluted series of romantic and financial manipulations, including a supposedly wealthy new husband, an elaborate deception involving a prenuptial agreement, and eventually Marylin marrying Miles himself.

And that’s why she belongs on this list. For Marylin, marriage isn’t a commitment. It’s a hostile takeover.

But Miles is hardly an innocent victim. He’s a smug, wealthy divorce attorney who’s spent his career helping people protect their fortunes from their spouses. Marylin simply understands the rules of his game well enough to play it against him.

And beneath all the manipulation, there’s the possibility that these two genuinely love one another.

Which is perhaps the most disturbing thing about the entire movie.

Marylin Rexroth: a bride who considers a wedding ring less a symbol of eternal love than a down payment on a very expensive divorce.


The Heartless Woman – The Lobster (2015) — Angeliki Papoulia

In Yorgos Lanthimos’s The Lobster, Colin Farrell plays David, a newly single man who checks into a hotel where guests are given 45 days to find a romantic partner. Fail, and they’re transformed into an animal of their choosing.

Which, frankly, is still a better arrangement than some marriages I’ve seen.

The movie was Lanthimos’s first English-language feature, following his bizarre Greek films Dogtooth and Alps. It stars Farrell, Rachel Weisz, Olivia Colman, John C. Reilly, Ben Whishaw, and Léa Seydoux.

Made for approximately €4.2 million as a five-country European co-production, it earned about $17.6 million worldwide, won the Jury Prize at Cannes, and received an Oscar nomination for the screenplay by Lanthimos and his longtime collaborator Efthimis Filippou.

The film also features Angeliki Papoulia, who had previously appeared in Dogtooth and Alps, as a character known only as the Heartless Woman.

And she is exactly what her name suggests.

David decides that his best chance of survival is to pursue her, pretending to be equally cruel and unemotional so that they’ll be considered compatible.

They eventually become an officially recognized couple and move into the hotel’s accommodations reserved for successful pairings.

But the Heartless Woman suspects David isn’t quite as heartless as he claims, so she devises a test.

She murders his dog.

Which also happens to be his brother, who was previously transformed into a dog after failing to find a partner.

And when David breaks down over the death of his brother, she realizes he’s been lying about his emotional nature.

Now, there isn’t a conventional wedding ceremony here, but I consider her absolutely a bride. In this dystopian society, forming an officially recognized couple is effectively compulsory marriage. The hotel is a matrimonial processing center, and David has just selected what may be the worst possible partner in human history.

What’s fascinating is that neither character enters the relationship because of love. David is trying to avoid becoming an animal, and the Heartless Woman is looking for someone whose cruelty matches her own.

This isn’t a relationship. It’s a survival strategy built on mutual dishonesty.

And in a movie about the absurdity of society demanding that everyone find a partner, the Heartless Woman demonstrates what happens when superficial compatibility becomes more important than genuine human connection.

She doesn’t simply make a terrible bride because she’s incapable of love.

She makes a terrible bride because she regards compassion as a defect worthy of punishment.

And if murdering your future brother-in-law is part of the compatibility test, I’d hate to see what she has planned for the honeymoon.

I’m Mike, so I never need notes or make mistakes! :::raspberry sounds:::